
It's a hard-poached egg, sitting atop onion soup and garnished with steel cut oatmeal and chives. Mixing them all up isn't nearly as pretty, but it lets you enjoy the creamy flavor with a lilt of onion and the comfort and added texture of the oatmeal.
Seth hates eggs and he loved--loved--this.
In fact, our gushing comments throughout the meal seemed more appropriate for a Taylor Lautner fan club meeting than for chef James Syhabout's serene eight-month-old (and rapidly Michelin-starred) restaurant.
Commis is small and spare and we were lucky to sit at the chef's counter, where the team works quietly in a minimal kitchen space. things up dramatically. You select three courses for $59 and wine pairings are an additional $29.
Before the revelatory amuse, we enjoyed this little palate cleanser of hibiscus and jasmine soda. I was expecting a jolt of sweet, but the jasmine added almost a nutty flavor.

True to form, I grilled our very helpful server about which items off the small menu were not to be missed. I never would have selected a duck entree, or a chicory salad without his guidance, but my risk paid off in two memorable dishes.
First, the salad of shredded chicory.

The greens sits atop a layer of goose liver mousse, and the creamy, gamey flavor mellows the bitterness. There is also some extra-sour sourdough bread layered in there, along with some "fowl juices," a term that will always look funny printed on a menu.
Seth chose a plate of sweet young carrots, baked in wood embers for a bit of an ashy flavor. The sweetness was undercut by a sunchoke cream and some tiny radishes in sweet mustard.

I'm still shocked neither of us chose the sweetbreads.
Again, I hardly ever order duck, but the pink-tender roast Muscovy breast was so delicate that a tiny bit of honey in the dish came through clear as a bell.

The duck breast was impressive enough without the 18-hour confit that accompanied it. Sweet holy renderings. A parsnip cream sauce and some dried black cherries added a few layers. The only disappointment was the salad of nettles.
Seth called dibs on the braised beef cheeks with bone marrow vinaigrette, served with black trumpet mushrooms and potatoes roasted in marjoram.

Desserts were just as complex. I ended up with a milk chocolate tile with burnt vanilla gelato, cocoa crumbs.

Seth selected the goat's milk panna cotta with pistachios and a sorbet of blood orange and beets.

Commis is a special meal regardless, but I think that the price tag versus the experience makes it the best value in Bay Area fine dining.
The spare white room and dual focus on ingredients and innovation sent my mind wandering back to Schwa in Chicago. Syhabout and Schwa chef Michael Carlson are both powerfully creative, and they execute their small-scale restaurant visions in very different ways.
The NY Times and Wall Street Journal seem to mention Commis in a dining story just about every week, and I was feeling a bit of hype fatigue before our dinner. Not so any more. It's nice to find a place that is deserving of its buzz. I can't wait to return and try the special counter-only chef's menu they are rolling out this month.
Commis
3859 Piedmont, Oakland
www.commisrestaurant.com
























































































